I Paid $108 for an app

I think It’s fairly typical for people to not really blink an eye when spending hundreds of dollars to pay for a smartphone, but then really second-guess at spending a buck for an app. I’m definitely like this. I rarely buy an app, unless it’s super important to me.

One type of app I’ve been consistently let down by are dictionary apps. The first one I tried was Websters. It starts off well enough, but after every word lookup, there is an ad. Not just an ad, but a full-screen un-skippable timed ad. It seems very egregious for an app that just looks up words.

I got tired of it and tried a different app; the Oxford Dictionary. It started off on a worse foot. It started with a plea for purchasing a subscription ($30 a year!) to use it ad-free, then asked me to accept push notifications before I even got to the main screen for the first time. It has an ad at the bottom, and then another full-screen ad between word lookups.

I deleted that one immediately.

Being so annoyed, I set out to make my own dictionary app with no ads or tracking. The first step was to get an Apple Developer account, which costs $99 plus tax ($108).

I’ve been familiar with Dict.Org for as long as I can remember. They are a repository of public domain dictionaries and serve them without any ads and have a public API.

I made a simple app that allows the user to select from the available dictionaries, query the results, and clean up the returned text a little bit. It also highlights words so the user can click them to look up them up with along with some minimal navigation arrows.

No frills. No amazing features. No ads. Just a boring dictionary app.

It’s been a long time since I’ve dabbled with the App Store. Honestly, the last time I worked on an App was probably 15 years ago. What surprised me most about the whole endeavor was how many hoops there are to jump through. Here are some of the hoops I jumped through on the journey to the App Store:

  • Provide 3 iPhone screen shots (clear direction is given, but it took me some time to find the proper templates and blank iPhone imagery. They need to be screenshots from a modern device with Dynamic Island)
  • Provide 3 iPad screen shots (same as above)
  • A dedicated webpage explaining the privacy policy of the app
  • A dedicated webpage explaining the options for tech support
  • Choose which countries and territories could have my app in their App Stores
  • Rate the app for appropriateness for children (I went with 13+ because I suppose you could look up naughty words)
  • Additional disclosures about services, privacy, etc.

After 2 days, my app got rejected. They wanted additional information because it was the first submission of this app. They wanted…

  • A screen recording from a physical device showing how the app works
  • A description of the intended purpose and target audience
  • Instructions for setting up and accessing the apps main features
  • A list of external services used
  • Regional differences for the app
  • Information about whether this app works in a highly regulated industry

Most of this seems very self-evident from seeing what had already been submitted…. But I complied. A little more than 2 weeks later, the app was rejected again. This time because…

The app name and screenshots include references to the price of the app or the service it provides, which is not considered an appropriate part of these metadata items.

Note that references to free or discounted services are considered a price reference and are not appropriate for app metadata.

Since the app was named “FreeDict” and I was advertising it as Free, Ad-Free, and Subscription-Free, it was violating these rules. I had to go redo all the screenshots, and rename the app. Now it’s called LexiDict. I resubmitted again. (Note that all these resubmissions actually required no changed to the code or executable; they are all related to the App Store meta data…)

Although most of these requests seem reasonable, altogether it felt like a lot just to get a simple app out in the open.

In the end, I spent less than a day making the app, and over 4 weeks getting it submitted and reviewed. But finally, it’s here. You can download the extremely basic, minimally featured, ad-free FreeDict LexiDict from the App Store.

Aqua Pill Graphic

At MacWorld in 2000, Steve Jobs introduced the world to “Aqua”. Aqua was the interface of the upcoming OS X. It was meant to be beautiful, and as Steve put it, “lickable”. The UI wasn’t universally well-received in its time. Some people mocked it saying it looked like an OS for children, or that it looked silly and too colorful. I loved it right away and saw it as making computing much more beautiful and fun.

OS X used the Aqua UI for quite a long time. The UI was toned down over time. The pin-striping was more muted in Panther (10.3), then removed altogether in Lion (10.5). Brushed metal was replaced with a less textured grey as well. Yosemite (10.0) saw the exit of glossy UI elements. Buttons no longer had a glossy sheen, but were a flat gradient, and we’ve been living in this flat UI from then up until Liquid Glass was introduced.

Liquid Glass was introduced in Mac OS 26 Tahoe. It too was not universally well-received. I was even hesitant because I was afraid there would be too much visual noise, or too much effort being wasted on rendering the subtle distortions in the glass effects.

When I upgraded to Mac OS 27 Golden Gate, I completely changed my mind. What changed my mind was noticing how glossy and beautiful the title bar buttons are. I was instantly reminded of Aqua and how much more fun they looked than they have for years as flat-colored circles.

I thought that as a tribute to Aqua I’d recreate the original graphic Steve Jobs used in his keynote presentation. I made this in Affinity using only vector tools. Below is a 30-second time-lapse showing the complete 8 minutes process from start to finish.

Crafting A Souvenir for Adam Savage

From Mythbusters to YouTube, I’ve always enjoyed watching Adam Savage and his various exploits. He has an enthusiasm that is contagious. I learned about a month ago that he would be visiting Fan-X in Salt Lake City, and I thought it would be a fun opportunity to meet him in person.

I wanted to make something for him in order to make the experience hopefully memorable to both parties. About 5 years ago, he had a whole series of videos where he made the Samaritan gun from the movie Hellboy. It was something that was clearly very meaningful for him. I thought perhaps I could make an accessory to accompany that prop. I also wanted it to be a bit different enough that it would be something no one else would think to create.

I decided to make a tiny Samaritan gun housed within a full-sized bullet for the Samaritan. I think it’s kind of random, but has a good chance of being something Adam would find humorous.

Firstly, I needed plans. I had a hard time finding any explicit dimensions for the bullets. I know they are 22mm, and typically when referring to a round, the measure is applied to the projectile, and not the casing. With that in mind, I found a photo of a screen-used prop and made some measurements based off of the one known dimension.

The next step was creating a tiny gun. I was going to 3d print this, but I didn’t know anyone with a working SLA printer, and apparently you many online printing services won’t allow you to print anything gun-shaped (even if it’s less than an inch big)! I ended up sculpting it out of clay and painting it. It was fun to try to get it to be recognizable even without the ability to add as much detail as I was wanting in my head. In the end, I liked the result and it felt more heartfelt than just printing something.

The next step was turning some brass to be the casing. I used my mini-lathe and some 1″ brass bar stock. This was straight forward.

Once I had the casing, I could then create the buck for the bullet. I used some poplar dowel and turned it, shaping it by hand. I filled the wood and sanded, painted, repeat until it was as smooth as I could get.

I used the buck to create a mold. I tried 2 part molding putty, but it was not very successful. I ended up with some weird voids and bubbles. I purchased some silicone mould maker and it was very effective. I ended up with zero voids, and it had a real nice finish.

Last I needed to cast the resin bullet. Thankfully I was smart enough to test this before committing my tiny gun. The first time, I didn’t follow the instructions. I ended up with lots of bubbles and some soft spots. The second time, I followed the instruction which indicated to heat the 2 resin parts prior to mixing. This improved the flow and reduced the number of bubbles.

It still wasn’t what I hoped for, so the final step was to use my brother-in-law’s vacuum chamber to vacuum out the bubbles after mixing, but before pouring. I suspended the gun in the mold using acrylic rod and a jig. I let it cure, and was very happy with the result. After polishing and clear coating, it looked as good as I could have hoped for.

The next step was to meet Adam and give it to him. I’ve never been to a con before, so I didn’t know what to expect. I purchased a photo op beforehand thinking that would be the best way to meet him. I arrived about an hour before my appointment to look around, and figure out what the line situation was. I saw Adam at his table, but was afraid to approach as it seemed it was necessary to pay to either get an autograph or to take a selfie. Neither seemed appropriate since I was going to get a photo in just an hour, so I didn’t approach.

The photo-op experience was not what I was expecting. They funneled us into a big line, and they had us going in, getting a photo, and leaving all within seconds. I was able to say “Nice to meet you”, and then they snapped a photo, and I barely had time to say “May I give you a gift?” Adam was nice, and took it but didn’t have time to open it then. I was funneled out as quickly as I had come in. Apparently this is the nature of these photo-ops, and being a con-newbie, I had no idea.

(You can see the gift in my hand)

I was glad to have met him. I hope he is able to open the gift and appreciate it. He seemed like a lovely person. I hope someday I get to actually have a conversation with him.

© 2007-2015 Michael Caldwell